Social sharing of Amazon purchases ruled illegal by Germans

By Chris Dawson February 1, 2016 - 9:03 pm

Social Media FeatYou buy something online, the next thing that happens is the retailer or marketplace gives you the option to share your purchase on Facebook, twitter, any of the other social media platforms out there or possibly even by email.

Personally I’ve never understood why someone would want to make their purchases public, but it makes a ton of sense for the retailer and some people are naturally unable to stop themselves from sharing everything from their latest meal to the pair of shoes they’ve just purchased. There’s nothing wrong with that.

Or at least there was nothing wrong with sharing purchases on social media until a German court stepped in and ruled it was illegal for Amazon to offer a social media sharing feature.

emailReuters report that sharing via email without prior approval of the recipient is illegal. It is “unsolicited advertising and unreasonable harassment”. Germany’s legal bods have already ruled that Facebook encouraging users to invite their friends to join Facebook is also illegal.

In the Amazon ruling, the case was bought by an Amazon third party retailer against one of their competitors. It’s worth remembering that German retailers habitually sue each other, for what in the UK we’d consider the most frivolous of reasons.

For instance if you omit to put a customer support telephone number in your T’s and C’s another retailer can sue you as it cost’s money for them to provide a support number and the reasoning goes that it’s unfair competition as you can operate more cheaply. It doesn’t matter if you’ve just started up and not sold a thing or if you’re not a direct competitor, they’ll sue you regardless.

What implications this has for the UK we don’t know. We’re also not sure how suing an Amazon third party retailer will get Amazon to change their ways and withdraw the email sharing feature. However if you sell on Amazon Germany and one of your customers decides to share a purchase from you with Amazon’s email sharing feature then technically you’re breaking the law.

  • 1 year ago

    ” However if you sell on Amazon Germany and one of your customers decides to share a purchase from you with Amazon’s email sharing feature then technically you’re breaking the law.”
    How can you as the vendor be held responsible for the actions of a customer?

    • 1 year ago

      That’s the Germans for you. It’s the way retailers out there keep other honest or mote often how a start up that’s never sold anything makes a quick buck out if their competitors.

  • Tony C
    1 year ago

    They should also make it illegal to leave towels on sunbeds.

  • james
    1 year ago

    thats not social sharing.
    an email is not social media.
    its just…. wrong all over.

  • 1 year ago

    All this sueing. Is it done under German Law or is it yet another example of EU Law? Off course if it is EU Law it could mean that some UK Solicitor could discover it and advise their Clients to use it whenever it is relevent (or knowing Solicitors when it is not Relevent).

Recent Comments

3 hours ago
Lee Pearce: We are getting the tracking for Large Letter items now, started a couple of weeks...
4 hours ago
James: Thats okay, I just thought I would double check, yes I think they pulled all...
6 hours ago
Raj: Royalmail Delivery confirmation with 2D barcode is only for parcels. Letters and large letters sent...
7 hours ago
Eggyplops: Isn't that a screenshot from the 'Money For Nothing' video by Dire Straits..?...
7 hours ago
Andy R: The 2 key benefits of schemes e.g., the Flat Rate Scheme, are that you get...