eBay is now editing Item Titles rather than ending listings that break the rules

By Dan Wilson January 4, 2016 - 9:21 am

eBay has a massive number of rules. Indeed the array of regulations and and guidelines can seem quite dizzying. In particular, eBay takes a dim rule on listings that have titles that have misleading brand names in the title (keyword spamming).

In the past eBay has simply removed listings that might break its rules and left it to sellers to relist and correct the offending listings. That is an inconvenience for such sellers but does give them control to make amends. And, of course, some of the infractions may well have been unintentional.

However, according to reports, it now seems that eBay isn’t ending listings it considers to be breaking the rules but is rather editing the seller generated Item Titles so they comply with the eBay listing policies.

eBay is informing sellers that the Item Titles have been amended and this is the text of one email to a seller that we’ve seen reported online: “We’re reaching out to you because one or more of your listings didn’t follow our guidelines. Because you’re a valued member of our community, your listing was edited so that it now meets our guidelines. It’s still live on our site. You can find a list of what was edited further down in this email.”

How do you feel about this? On one level, it can easily be appreciated that such an action is better than having a listing ended by eBay. But equally, letting eBay amend your listings is a big deal. And it is by no means certain that a) they’ll do it properly or b) they’re interpretation of the eBay rules means they’re right to do so.

What do you think?

  • Tinker
    2 years ago

    Good luck to them , not enough humans available or processing power in nasa computers to correct them all,and it keeps the ebay vigilantes busy

  • Rai
    2 years ago

    I don’t mind as long as I get an up to date list of changes – a big gripe with amazons changing/merging of titles & products is the reports are too slow to catch any incorrect changes.

  • Tinker
    2 years ago

    No doubt its self financing ,
    Its fees ebay will be concerned about not correctness

  • David Brackin
    2 years ago

    Great news. eBay’s rules — we all want to comply with them, but they are labyrinthine. Any seller with a lot of SKUs is bound to get caught out from time to time. What decent people want is help complying with the rules, not a large stick threatening them for occasional minor infractions.

    Of course I wonder what happens when the listing change is picked-up by Linnworks or other similar listing software. Will it spot that there’s been an unauthorised change and simply flip the listing back?

    Watch this space for sellers getting told off for unamending the errors…

    • james
      2 years ago

      ebays interpretation of ebay rules is “we’ll do whatever the hell we like, what are you going to do about it?”

    • tinker
      2 years ago

      “eBay’s rules — we all want to comply with them,”
      NOT US ,
      fair play honesty and decency are our rules,

  • Mark
    2 years ago

    This should only happen to listings which are only slightly non-compliant.

    Listings which are taking the piss should be canceled as they were deliberately badly listed.

  • Gary
    2 years ago

    So ebay now admit that policy breaking threats really are idle which will result in the opposite effect to that desired creating even more work for the ebay police. An idea of an empire building department head honcho maybe? Wouldn’t it be easier to simply have a search that gives buyers the result they want rather than one that ebay thinks they want? Then there would be less incentive to try and beat the system.

    • james
      2 years ago

      well best match appears to be broken again anyway, so maybe they will.

  • Paul
    2 years ago

    Are they putting ‘L@@K’ in the revised titles?

Recent Comments

19 mins ago
northumbrian: seems common sense and reasonable to us if anyone came into our shop and encouraged...
20 mins ago
Naem: Hi, Leader of the Banned. I agree with you that they do not have many products...
35 mins ago
s: Nasty way of punishing sellers for doing nothing wrong and personally I would switch to...
42 mins ago
Andy R: and now THIS.... We’ve updated the eBay.​co.​ukUser Agreement. These changes are effective immediately for new members and...